Monthly Archives: January 2008

Oh God. It’s Rowan…

I fear that Sunny may has spoken a little too soon (see comments):

I doubt very much we’d run general Richard Dawkins style posts calling all people of faith ‘delusional’ just to have a big slagging match.

…because yours truly and the Archbishop of Canterbury are about to have a bit of a ‘falling out’ over some of the content of his James Callaghan Memorial Lecture.

(I should qualify that opening by saying that I’m not about to call all ‘people of faith’ delusional – that’s a subject for a different time and venue and a matter for philosophical rather than political discussion – and I’m not trying to simply generate a ‘slagging match’ either – although one can never quite guarantee that one will not ensue when taking a pop at religion and religious thinking, but what follows does have more than the odd hint of Dawkins/Hitch/Grayling about it in the sense that I’m about to take a shot at dismantling some poorly constructed ‘religious’ arguments advanced by the Archbish, so consider yourself warned in advance and don’t assume that anything that follows is necessarily easy or straightforward as we’re delving in philosophy for part of this).

The full text of Rowan William’s speech has rapidly been transcribed and appears on his website here, which means that, for once, I’m not going to have to rely on second hand quotations drawn from media sources where its difficult to ascertain the extent to which reporting has been editorialised and what follows is not a full-on fisk as I’m intending to work with extracts that illustrate the points I wish to make.

So let’s start at the beginning and note that the subject of the lecture is ‘Religious Hatred and Religious Offence’ and that William’s is heading off down entirely the wrong track right from the outset with his opening gambit: Continue reading

We need faith in fair minded politics

Kate Belgrave’s piece on Monday, Jesus. H. Christ. Rides. Again, refers to the “Jesus freaks” in Brown’s Cabinet and asks why followers of God still get airtime in politics and press. Kate’s piece well illustrates that many people – particularly those who take a left of centre approach to politics – either ignore or at least fail to acknowledge the power of faith in people’s lives.

With debate raging about the Embryology Bill, veils, faith schools and social cohesion, I wonder if it isn’t time for those who espouse the “progressive” agenda to debate just how to reconcile faith with our modern, pluralistic democracy.

We are not alone in struggling with this issue. In the United States Barack Obama has recently argued that his own party has been reluctant to engage in serious debate about the issue of religion and politics. Speaking back in June last year he said: “At best, we [Democrats] may try to avoid the conversation about religious values altogether, fearful of offending anyone and claiming that – regardless of our personal beliefs – constitutional principles tie our hands.”

The reality of political engagement is that we have to meet people where they are – even if we do not agree with where they are. If, as a progressive movement, we are to communicate our hopes and values in a way that is relevant to the lives of others, we cannot abandon the field of religious discourse. In his speech, Obama argued that secularists are wrong when they ask believers to leave their religion at the door before entering into public debate.
Continue reading

Casting the net – Glancing over the pond

Welcome to Casting the net, Liberal Conspiracy’s daily web review. As always, please feel free to share your own recommendations in the comments section.

Highlights
Daniel Finkelstein/Times – Are only left wing people allowed to have insights?
Da Fink treads the rickety rope-bridge of race in politics, and scores a cheap point en route.

Caroline Kennedy/NYT – A President Like My Father
This slipped under my radar until last night. JFK’s daughter on why Barack Obama is man who can inspire America again.

Matthew Yglesias/CiF – John Edwards’s indelible mark
Yglesias pays tribute to an honourable and visionary candidate steamrolled by fate.

Climate Change Denial – More Dire Ads
Have Calor Gas been grossly insensitive with their advertising?

Remembering the Ability in Disability – Jeremy Beadle Had A Disability?
Beadle was “a perfectly wonderful, amazing example of DisAbility”.

snowflake5 – The Vietnam Factor
Is actual war-experience, particularly time in Vietnam, actually a hindrance to nominees running for the post of Commander-in-Chief? An excellent analysis.

Malcolm Redfellow revivus – 11 months, 22 days … and counting
Is the GOP close to total electoral collapse?

Elsewhere
New Humanist Blog – Texas may sanction creationism “degree”
Bloggerheads – Thinking of hiring Iain Dale as a speaker on blogging? Think again.
The World after Bush – McCain up, Edwards out, Giuliani never in
Cassilis – Final thoughts on Iain Dale & Derek Conway…
donpaskini – Sharing the proceeds of growth
Left of Centrist – A two “man” race
Westminster Wisdom – McA-Levels
Spy Blog – European Arrest Warrant extradition to Spain – Law Lords overturn habeus corpus for Farid Hilali

If you would like your blog or site to be considered as source material for future reviews, drop me an email at aaronh [at] liberalconspiracy [dot] org with the relevant url. I can then enter it into my RSS reader and monitor it for suitable content to be included. Likewise, if you have a specific article/post you feel deserves a little more traffic, get in touch.

Can we create a ‘Progressive Immigration Policy’?

Over 150 people crammed into committee room 9 last night for a lively and informed debate on migration. The meeting was chaired by the country’s leading social policy commentator Polly Toynbee. The debate first heard from the Minister for Immigration, Liam Byrne who set out the reasons why he believes the policies being implemented by Labour are “firm but fair”.

Byrne drew on his own heritage as the decendent of a migrant family coming to work in the UK. Forwarding a “work hard and play by the rules” argument Bryne drew on the economic arguments for a progressive immigration policy and even touched on the moral ones. However, when it came to answering a question on what the differences were between Tory and New Labour policies Bryne did seem to struggle.

Byrne was followed by an impassioned speech by Don Flynn of the Migrants’ Rights Network, and editor of the Compass publication, Towards a Progressive Immigration Policy, who set out a critical view of the government’s record and called on the government ‘to stop moving the goal posts’, strongly urging that the government put social justice at the heart of policy, in order for its rhetoric to live up to the reality.
Continue reading

‘Would you like a qualification with that?’

The Daily Telegraph website reported on Monday the story that McDonald’s is to be empowered to issue A-levels with an entirely predictable sneer: ‘Would you like a qualification with that?’

The trouble is, that nasty little middle-class jibe reflects the reality on the ground for any kids naïve enough to undergo the course – perhaps with no little arm-twisting from the local JobCentre – in the expectation that they will come out of it with a piece of paper standing them in good stead in any function other than flipping burgers.

They will be following in the tradition of generations of polytechnic students who swallowed the spurious assurance that they would be accorded ‘parity of esteem’ with the products of Oxbridge. They weren’t; indeed, the polytechnic stigma subsequently may even have worked against many in the job market.
Continue reading

Casting the net – Tory tortoises and those damn patio-heaters

Welcome to Casting the net, Liberal Conspiracy’s daily web review. As always, please feel free to share your own recommendations in the comments section.

Highlights
Hopi Sen – The Con Way?
Cameron’s actions over the Coway scandal were self-serving and weak.

The Last Ditch – Leaving medicine
Libertarian Tom Paine takes on “socialised medicine” and the increasing number of doctors leaving the NHS.

Dave Cole – Why I intend to vote for Ken Livingstone
It’s the transport infrastructure (and housing), stupid.

Nick Robinson – Who else is on the payroll?
Nick’s gone with “Conway PLC“, but I preferred my “pocket-money Conway”. Oh hum.

Sunder Katwala/CiF – Long march of the Tory tortoises
Cameron has been proven a charlatan. Change to win? Pah! They haven’t changed at all.

Obsolete – Express-watch: Soft touch journalists.
The Express wouldn’t be misleading us again, would it?

The Yorkshire Guidon – Liberal Democrats to ban patio heaters
Will the Lib Dems outlaw patio-heaters? What, with no debate?

janestheone – Jack’s the man
Jack Straw for leader? Surely not!

Bob Piper – Winter of Discontent brewing in Shamblestown
The LibDem council in Liverpool may be a shower, but Bob thinks he can convince you that the Tory/Lib coalition in Brum is even worse.

Elsewhere
Jenni Russell/CiF – We rage at Hain and Conway but miss the real profligacy
Amused Cynicism – More on McA-levels
Remembering the Ability in Disability – Neighbours Forgets The Ability in Disability… again!
Crooked Timber – Prediction Markets In Republican Spin
Dave Hill/CiF – Round one to Ken
Freemania – Conway, Hain, dithering and decisiveness
Fair Deal Phil – Hillary wins hollow victory in Florida: will Giuliani now back McCain…?

If you would like your blog or site to be considered as source material for future reviews, drop me an email at aaronh [at] liberalconspiracy [dot] org with the relevant url. I can then enter it into my RSS reader and monitor it for suitable content to be included. Likewise, if you have a specific article/post you feel deserves a little more traffic, get in touch.

Will Florida change everything?

Results from the Republican vote in Florida should be coming in soon. I have a feeling (I’m hoping!) Mitt Romney will win. Why? Because it derails McCain’s campaign somewhat, who is the biggest threat to Obama since he attracts a lot of centrists. Florida should also mark the end of Rudy Giulian’s short-lived campaign.
Update:
- Hillary Clinton wins Democrat vote, but gets no delegates.
- John McCain wins for Republicans; Romney close; Giuliani third; Huckabee fourth.
- Giuliani should drop out before Super Tuesday, endorsing McCain.
- Huckabee will stay till Super Tuesday, but most likely drop out after that.
- Top Republicans should be working overtime to kill McCain’s campaign now.
Continue reading

Casting the net – The Derek “Pocket-money” Conway special

Welcome to Casting the net, Liberal Conspiracy’s daily web review. As always, please feel free to share your own recommendations in the comments section.

Highlights
Guardian – Tory MP facing suspension ‘paid another son’
Derek Conway has paid his son more than £40,000 of taxpayers money – during which time junior was at university. A second son was given £32,000 while also at uni. Conway’s chum, Iain Dale, is getting all hissy because anonymous commenters are goading him on his blog. No comment.

Quaequam Blog! – Derek Conway and the passions of Iain Dale
James Graham tackles conman Conway.

PoliticalHackUK – Imagine, if you will
As does the Hack.

Bob Piper – Stand by your man
Bob is more interested in Mr. Dale’s silence.

Conservative Home – Cameron makes the wrong choice on Conway
The Tories do their nut as Slippery Dave sits on his hands.

Charlie Brooker/CiF – A rogue trader loses £3.7bn. Further proof that the stock market is nothing more than a fantasy world
Last week’s Société Générale scandal just proves what a crock the stock market is.

Bloggerheads – MessageSpace is distributing copyrighted material without permission
Guido gets all legal, again (see comments).

The Diary of Chris K – MP faces child assault investigation
Not a good few days for David Cameron as another Tory MP hits the headlines.

westmonster – Florida’s two-ring circus
The Sunshine State goes to the polls. Westmonster has the rub.

The Existentialist Cowboy – A Genius, A Saint, and SCOTUS Agree: Conspiracies Exist!
Having spent decades talking about the great communist conspiracy, rightwingers now dismiss conspiracies and ridicule those who challenge the status quo.

Elsewhere
Cassilis – Hari on Amis…
New Humanist Blog – Islam’s scientific golden age
donpaskini – Skillz
Neil Harding – The Final Nail In British Democracy.
Jonathan Fryer – Europe’s Growing Liberal Family
Mars Hill – Derek Conway
Martin Gill/LDV – Opinion: Choosing our Judges
Omar’s Blog – Latest poll sees boost in support for Ken
Dave Winer – Find a shared vision, v2.0

If you would like your blog or site to be considered as source material for future reviews, drop me an email at aaronh [at] liberalconspiracy [dot] org with the relevant url. I can then enter it into my RSS reader and monitor it for suitable content to be included. Likewise, if you have a specific article/post you feel deserves a little more traffic, get in touch.

Jesus. H. Christ. Rides. Again.

This is a quick blog to update LC readers on the latest god-based outrage against women. As most of you probably know, Gordon Brown’s cabinet contains a number of career Jesus freaks – Ruth Kelly and Des Browne are the main offenders, and there are a couple of other perpetrators whose names and point in our lives escape me for the moment.

Anyway – Ruthie and her fellow holy-rollers have revealed themselves concerned that the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Bill will make it possible for lesbians to avail themselves of IVF and become parents.

I’m still trying to grasp the exact reasons why the thought of a couple of dykes pushing a pram is considered such a disaster – who gives a stuff, basically – but I’ll go out on a limb for you here and posit the theory that the big concern is that two women who bring a child up without male input will wash its hair and teach it to bake and turn it into a Gay.

Horrors.

The Human Fertilisation and Embryology Bill is dear to our hearts here at LC, not least because we’re trying to stop followers of the Lord amend the Abortion Act through it.

Now it appears that Gordon Brown’s cabinet is peopled by people who are concerned that letting lesbians in on the reproductive act will upset Jesus H (who, let’s not forget, is only a made-up person, like Big Bird or Po) and spell the end of the traditional nuclear family unit. Continue reading