Welcome to Casting the net, Liberal Conspiracy’s daily web review. As always, please feel free to share your own recommendations in the comments section. Today’s links could care less what you do with them once they’re dead. Why? Because they’d be dead.
Organ Grinding
Watch out for Dizzy “Thinks” accusing Justin of writing an “intellectually vapid piece”. Apparently, Justin now refuses to come out of his room until Dizzy apologises.
Justin McKeating – Monkeys and the organ minder
Cassilis – After death there is no ‘you’…
Polly Toynbee/CiF – Living people matter. When you’re dead, you’re dead
Bob Piper – Mouth… organs
Libby Purves/Times – Whose body is it anyway?
Dizzy Thinks – Lots of nonsense on organ donations from Liberal Conspiracy and elsewhere
Iain Dale – Brown Wants to Nationalise Our Bodies
The Diary of Chris K – The Organ Grinder…
The Yorksher Gob – Organ Donation
Sim-O’s Random Thoughts – What to do with the offal?
Thomas Sutcliffe – Have a heart and sign up to organ donation
Tony’s Blog – Much offal
Vino S – In favour of an ‘opt-out’ system of organ donation
So, how about this: we let the Tories win this one, and the dead are burned and buried, complete with all their gooey bits. Oh, and more people die. What a result, eh?
Elsewhere
Though Cowards Flinch – The Role of the State
Seema Malhotra/Compass – Westminster’s democratic deficit shames political system
Jon Worth – British press and the EU: yesterday numberplates, today sausages
Mike Allen/Politico – Clinton, Obama seek truce on race row
Chicken Backup – The Profligate Peter Hain
Skipper – Peter Hain Looks Like ‘Toast’
DM Andy’s blog – It’s election day… in Barbados
yourfriendinthenorth – Ware did it all go wrong?
Westminster Wisdom – The Political Theory of Reservoir Dogs
Mike Rouse – News at Ten Returns
Dave Cole – Stop the War Coalition and Channel Four
Also, check out the New Statesman, which is running a series of pieces on “Life After Bush.”
If you would like your blog or site to be considered as source material for future reviews, drop me an email at aaronh [at] liberalconspiracy [dot] org with the relevant url. I can then enter it into my RSS reader and monitor it for suitable content to be included. Likewise, if you have a specific article/post you feel deserves a little more traffic, get in touch.
post to del.icio.us |
Oh FFS – here we go again, not that LC is a *party* political site, oh no…
I don’t think the organ thing is a Tory / Lab issue is it?
I agree. It’s more of a counter-Enlightenment / Enlightenment issue.
chrisc
Lighten up dude. I’m certainly not being party political (see here for my thoughts of Mr. Brown), it’s just that most of the faux-outrage appears to be coming from the Tory bloggers.
I’d add Matt SInclair’s post to the group http://sinclairsmusings.blogspot.com/2008/01/i-have-to-believe-that-when-my-eyes-are.html
How is it an enlightenment/counter enlightenment issue Justin? I’d have thought the argument that we own our own bodies is a very Lockian one- whereas the argument that our bodies and ourselves by extension are only useful as part of a whole is more of a Romantic position. This is one I’m still thinking through- but I don’t think the answer is simple.
You can have my kidney, when you pry it from my cold dead hand (and other stories to frighten the children)
Great post Ian, cheers for the link
The more I see of this debate, the more I wonder what it would have looked like if the proposal to presume consent had been made by the Tories.
As another thought: to what other areas should the doctrine of presumed consent by extended?
Medical procedures? Taxes? Charitable donations? Life insurance?
Well there is already presumed consent for simple medical procedures so there’s nothing new here…and what exactly is optional about paying your taxes in todays world?
Comrade, we presume you consent to give the state 100% of your income. If you wish to opt out, here is a fifteen thousand page form to fill in.
Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.
10 Comments 21 Comments 7 Comments 14 Comments 5 Comments 24 Comments 36 Comments 29 Comments 33 Comments 9 Comments |
LATEST COMMENTS » Sunny Hundal posted on Labour leaders debate on Newsnight: quick thoughts » Alex posted on Bloody Sunday: when it's right to reopen history » Robert posted on Here comes that Digital Election we have been waiting for » John posted on These union elections are just as important for Labour » Charlie 2 posted on Bloody Sunday: when it's right to reopen history » Matthew Stiles posted on Labour leaders debate on Newsnight: quick thoughts » jim posted on Labour leaders debate on Newsnight: quick thoughts » Sean posted on Labour leaders debate on Newsnight: quick thoughts » matgb posted on Labour leaders debate on Newsnight: quick thoughts » Matthew Stiles posted on Labour leaders debate on Newsnight: quick thoughts » eastender posted on Labour leaders debate on Newsnight: quick thoughts » Rich G posted on Labour leaders debate on Newsnight: quick thoughts » Bob B posted on Survey: Tory cuts are 'depressing confidence' » PDF posted on Labour leaders debate on Newsnight: quick thoughts » former Para posted on Bloody Sunday: when it's right to reopen history |