A political opponent of the Scottish Socialist Party once quipped: ‘Elect six Trotskyites to the Scottish parliament, and the most radical thing they can come up with is a demand for free school meals’.
That criticism was coming from the right, as it happens. But it’s exactly the sort of sneering remark one can readily imagine on the lips of that certain breed of public school-educated far leftist who has succeeded in memorising the Transitional Programme word for word. Free school meals? Call yourselves revolutionaries?
Actually, when the SSP first started campaigning on the question in 2001, I thought it was quite a politically savvy thing to do. The is just the sort of concrete policy that many working class people will instantly see as making a difference to their lives.
It’s not just a question of the cash, as the SSP pointed out; there are also the very real issue among cool-conscious teenagers of the stigma attached to qualifying for a ‘handout’. Growing up as one of only two boys on free school meals in a middle-class dominated Grammar School, I’m well aware of that one.
Top that off with increased recognition of the public health concerns surrounding obesity and nutrition, particularly on the home turf of deep-fried Mars Bars, and the case is compelling.
What’s more, New Labour and the Lib Dems – parties that would, in another time and place, have come up with exactly the kind of progressive reform the idea of free school meals encapsulates – were forced to oppose such a seemingly modest reform. In 2002, they voted down an SSP bill to implement the proposal. It couldn’t possibly be afforded, you understand.
As ‘exposure demands’ that highlight the limitations of reformism in the eyes of the class go, comrades, it doesn’t get any better than that.
The SSP imploded in 2006 and lost its representation in the Scottish parliament the following year. Some of the circumstances surrounding the break up are shortly to be debated in a perjury trial, so I’ll say no more on this score.
But now the SSP are not around in Holyrood to take the credit, the policy is all of a sudden safe, at least in a dramatically watered-down version. So the Scottish National Party has today announced that all children will from 2010 get free school meals for their first three years in primary school.
Nationally, New Labour has established a free school meals pilot scheme in Hull, and unions and even some Labour MP are pushing the call. But the role of the SSP in all this is seemingly being airbrushed out; there’s no mention of it in the BBC’s coverage, for instance.
Most unfair, say I. Those SSP members who initiated and pushed the policy should take a bow. And the entire British left should be very proud of them. Small as the step may seem to a brand of politics committed to world revolution, it is one of the far left’s most significant practical achievements for many years.
post to del.icio.us |
Policies are rarely judged solely on merit or in ignorance of who’s advancing them. It became a media trope 4/5 years ago that policies that polled very well among the public dropped from view when they were revealed as Tory policies.
Likewise with things like PFI and independent schooling – these things were an anathema to the left until Blair started to talk about them. They didn’t suddenly get whole-hearted support but the opposition became more conditional and muted and the left were happy to turn a blind eye which they wouldn’t have done had a Tory government implemented them – such is politics.
Hence the ridicule the policy attracted when it was pushed by a fringe political group (with, you must admit, a range of far more serious and significant policies in the drawer) but the acquiescence (if not support) when it comes from somewhere else….
To be fair I think there is still a lot of opposition to PFI on the left outside the Labour Party.
More amusingly, there’s also a great deal of opposition to PFI from halfwitted right-wingers who’re grumpy that a Labour government are doing it.
Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.
5 Comments 66 Comments 20 Comments 13 Comments 10 Comments 18 Comments 4 Comments 25 Comments 49 Comments 31 Comments |
LATEST COMMENTS » JonSHarvey posted on What would you ask the Labour leader candidates? » JonSHarvey posted on What would you ask the Labour leader candidates? » VS posted on What would you ask the Labour leader candidates? » JonSHarvey posted on What would you ask the Labour leader candidates? » JonSHarvey posted on What would you ask the Labour leader candidates? » JonSHarvey posted on What would you ask the Labour leader candidates? » Barry Tebb posted on Video: police arrest Brian Haw for not moving aside quickly enough » JonSHarvey posted on What would you ask the Labour leader candidates? » Richard Bates posted on Complete tits » JonSHarvey posted on What would you ask the Labour leader candidates? » Dale posted on What would you ask the Labour leader candidates? » Dave Edwards posted on Ashcroft to launch "devastating" attack on Cameron » Liberal Conspiracy posted on Ashcroft to launch "devastating" attack on Cameron » Miss E. J. Frogster posted on Complete tits » Sarah AB posted on Complete tits |