For once, punishment fits crime


by Septicisle    
February 7, 2009 at 11:19 am

It’s good to see that good sense has prevailed in the case of Robert Holding, the 72-year-old milkman who also supplied his elderly customers with cannabis resin as a sideline, with Judge Lunt suspending the custodial sentence, despite him warning that he was likely to go to prison.

The ostensible reason is that Holding’s wife, who has Alzheimer’s, has gone into a care home and that in an “act of mercy”, the judge suspended the sentence so he could continue to visit her. It would however be nice to think that perhaps he was influenced by some of the reporting of the case, with even the right-wing virulently anti-drug papers taking a quite apparent dim view of him being sent to prison for trying to help people with their pains, however misguided.

Further evidence to his “crime” being purely to help was that he was selling the drug at well below street prices, making more money on his milk round itself. If all dealers were so publicly spirited, the war on drugs would be even more of a clusterfuck.


---------------------------
  Tweet    


About the author
'Septicisle' is a regular contributor to Liberal Conspiracy. He mostly blogs, poorly, over at Septicisle.info on politics and general media mendacity.
· Other posts by
Filed under
Blog ,Crime


Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.


Reader comments


1. Shatterface

I dream of the day my milkman delivers cannabis.

If someone’s crime is supplying drugs, then for the punishment to fit the crime, the judge should give the felon some drugs. As I wrote on my old blog:

I propose that the punishment should fit the crime. If someone murders, they are killed. If someone steals, their property is taken.

If someone is found guilty of distributing drugs, the judge should give them some drugs. If someone’s crime is public nudity, the judge should appear before them nude. If someone facilitates gambling by opening an illegal gambling den, the judge should invite the felon round his house for a few games of poker. If a man is guilty of wanking off another man in a public toilet, the judge should… well I think you get the idea.

This would neatly end the problem of people being prosecuted for victimless crimes.

I don’t know whether to believe this guy or not. My problem is I’ve had plenty of clients who are 72 years old and they’re tough as nails in consultation, but before the court, they’re feeble elderly people who wouldn’t harm a fly. Do we actually believe his story? I think the judge probably had no choice but to give him the benefit of the doubt. There would have been a public outcry, whether the man’s liar or not.


Reactions: Twitter, blogs




    Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.

     
    Liberal Conspiracy is the UK's most popular left-of-centre politics blog. Our aim is to re-vitalise the liberal-left through discussion and action. More about us here.

    You can read articles through the front page, via Twitter or RSS feed. You can also get them by email and through our Facebook group.
    RECENT OPINION ARTICLES




    32 Comments



    10 Comments



    24 Comments



    83 Comments



    69 Comments



    20 Comments



    29 Comments



    45 Comments



    32 Comments



    45 Comments



    LATEST COMMENTS
    » the a&e charge nurse posted on Libdems approve obliteration of the NHS

    » Schmidt posted on We Libdems will need more than an apology if the NHS bill passes

    » the a&e charge nurse posted on Oi Daily Mail - who you calling a "Plastic" Brit?

    » jon posted on Libdems approve obliteration of the NHS

    » Just Visiting posted on The EDL and BNP start to join forces

    » Just Visiting posted on The EDL and BNP start to join forces

    » Abdul Abulbul Emir posted on Oi Daily Mail - who you calling a "Plastic" Brit?

    » Abdul Abulbul Emir posted on Oi Daily Mail - who you calling a "Plastic" Brit?

    » Trooper Thompson posted on Libdems approve obliteration of the NHS

    » Cylux posted on Libdems approve obliteration of the NHS

    » Mark Carrigan posted on The EDL and BNP start to join forces

    » Chaise Guevara posted on Oi Daily Mail - who you calling a "Plastic" Brit?

    » Kojak posted on Oi Daily Mail - who you calling a "Plastic" Brit?

    » Kojak posted on Oi Daily Mail - who you calling a "Plastic" Brit?

    » pat roche posted on We Libdems will need more than an apology if the NHS bill passes