Tory machine making excuses for second jobs
Second jobs, so we are told, help MPs to stay in touch with the real world and the needs of constituents.
David Cameron was quick to claim he is “relaxed” about more details of his shadow Cabinet’s outside earnings being made public this week under new transparency rules: “I do not think that a chamber full of professional politicians with no outside experience is a good thing,” he said.
Glossing over the fact that George Osborne’s entry on the Conservative website reads very much like that of a career politician (“after a short spell as a freelance journalist… he has since dedicated himself wholly to politics”), the question that needs to be asked is: “outside experience” of what?
William Hague, has been employed by private equity group Terra Firma since at least 2002; Oliver Letwin has had a long-term relationship with bankers Rothschild; Francis Maude is paid to advise Barclays; Andrew Mitchell, Merchant bank Lazards; Kenneth Clarke, private equity firm AgCapita Partners. The list is long.
The concern is only compounded by the fact that half of the shadow cabinet are directly funded by hedge fund managers and private equity bosses.
The Tory machine has been quick to reframe the issue of second jobs as one of valuable experience over conflicts of interest. But we should reflect on what we see rather than what we are told. Why else have transparency?
(This is an extract from a longer piece at politics.co.uk)
---------------------------
Tweet | Share on Tumblr |
This is a guest post. Tamasin Cave is a freelance writer and campaigner for among others SpinWatch and the Alliance for Lobbying Transparency
· Other posts by Tamasin Cave
Story Filed Under: Blog ,Conservative Party ,Our democracy ,Westminster
Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.
Reader comments
The funny thing is, it seems their “outside experience” is all the same kind of outside experience. Perhaps, if Cameron’s argument is a fair one, we should insist MPs with second jobs spend time in a range of jobs each year, including cleaning, agricultural labour, domestic labour etc
At the risk of sounding like Mark Knopfler, I think it’s a stretch to call sitting on the board of private equity firms and hedge funds actually “working” in the sense that it runs contrary to what the vast and sweeping majority of us define as work*.
The issue for me is not that these second “jobs” would distract them from their parliamentary duties, but the fact that, given the parlous state of the financial industry it’s a cocking *gigantic* conflict of interest to have a potentially incoming government up to their necks in said industry, raking in massive sums in the process.
And these are the kind of people who have the gall to say that public-sector jobs are “make-work”. Given that a council-employed youth officer probably has to come up with ways to keep gangs of lads from tearing strips out of each other day on day, and these buggers basically have to show up to the odd meeting, play golf and attend the right social gatherings, I strenuously beg to differ on who’s doing the “make-work”.
* – i.e. They do bugger all except lend their name and influence, maybe show up at meetings once or twice a month and get paid hundreds of thousands for it, whereas most of us have to work at least 5 days a week and have bugger-all left once we’ve put a roof over our head for the next month and fed ourselves.
Aren’t they supposed to get their outside experience BEFORE becoming MPs, rather than on-the-job?
Pretty much all MPs used to have second jobs once, why the change now?
To a certain extent I agree with Bluepillnation. Personally I don’t give a damn what their work outside parliament is, (in fact given the damage they do while in the Commons, the more time spent outside the better), but transparency is the key to show potential conflicts of interest. Any attempt to hide such conflicts should be considered criminal and charged appropriately. I would include EU pensions as a similar possible conflict.
Returning to the OP: the list of Conservative MPs and their employers is unconvincing for a counter argument, because they were the same people who would work together anyway. Disgraceful employment of MPs and former MPs occurs when there is a connection with past or future government office.
Hedge fund management and private equity is not illegal at this time.
Does the fact that so many Tories are associated with financial organisations concern me? It dismays me that Cameron thinks that an executive jolly is the same as real work. But he has never had a real job.
Reactions: Twitter, blogs
-
Liberal Conspiracy
Article: Tory machine making excuses for second jobs http://bit.ly/18l2Yc
-
Ultra Wealth
Liberal Conspiracy » Tory machine making excuses for second jobs http://tr.im/qLwE
-
Liberal Conspiracy
Article: Tory machine making excuses for second jobs http://bit.ly/18l2Yc
-
Corey Faustin
Liberal Conspiracy » Tory machine making excuses for second jobs http://bit.ly/EOBvC
-
Scott Perry
Liberal Conspiracy » Tory machine making excuses for second jobs http://bit.ly/yoETv
-
Ultra Wealth
Liberal Conspiracy » Tory machine making excuses for second jobs http://tr.im/qLwE
-
Corey Faustin
Liberal Conspiracy » Tory machine making excuses for second jobs http://bit.ly/EOBvC
Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.
You can read articles through the front page, via Twitter or RSS feed. You can also get them by email and through our Facebook group.
LATEST COMMENT PIECES
» ‘As many holes as a Swiss cheese’: how the UK tax system loses money abroad
» The Conservatives will regret appointing Tom Winsor as police chief
» Boycott Workfare – campaign to end forced unpaid work for benefits
» The SNP’s Weak Cultural Case for Independence
» The Guardian was absolutely right to publish the Hamas leader
» Gwyneth Paltrow, hip-hop and the ‘N’-word
» After years of calling us rape victims liars, the Met Police have relented
» Why Geert Wilders won’t find ‘Eurabia’ in America
» Ed Miliband needs to go further on Englishness
» Four reasons Europe’s austerity agenda may be coming to an end
» The Greens must get better at communicating our support for science
3 Comments 17 Comments 18 Comments 39 Comments 52 Comments 85 Comments 56 Comments 51 Comments 230 Comments 298 Comments |
LATEST COMMENTS » tigerdarwin posted on Where did £1.5m for Jubilee stewarding go? » tigerdarwin posted on Where did £1.5m for Jubilee stewarding go? » Unity posted on Michael Gove's u-turns on how children should be taught » willardexe posted on The tragedy behind the Sam Hallam case » Workfare Is Not ‘Fair’ At All: The Jubilee ‘Work Experience’ Scandal « Caroline Mortimer posted on Watch: Jon Stewart rips Jubilee TV coverage » So Much For Subtlety posted on The Guardian was absolutely right to publish the Hamas leader » SadButMadLad posted on Boycott Workfare - campaign to end forced unpaid work for benefits » Trooper Thompson posted on Ed Miliband starts to embrace Englishness » Kojak posted on Michael Gove's u-turns on how children should be taught » steveb posted on Boycott Workfare - campaign to end forced unpaid work for benefits » the a&e charge nurse posted on Greg Palast: new book The 'Vultures' » Dissident posted on Boycott Workfare - campaign to end forced unpaid work for benefits » damon posted on Gwyneth Paltrow, hip-hop and the 'N'-word » Trooper Thompson posted on Michael Gove's u-turns on how children should be taught » Unpaid Diamond Jubilee Stewards Were Forced to Sleep Under London Bridge - Nlyten.com posted on Where did £1.5m for Jubilee stewarding go? |