Published: July 8th 2009 - at 8:16 am

Tory sticks up two fingers at Boris, amidst cronyism


by Chris Barnyard    

Tory Assembly Member Brian Coleman refuses to publish his expenses while at the GLA. But will Boris Johnson have the guts to fire him?

Yesterday the full expenses for 24 London Assembly Members were revealed. But one remained – Coleman. He not only refused to publish them but the declared that because Boris asked him to publish them, he wouldn’t! He also said he would not help the “mad, bad and the sad, the bloggers on the internet” by publishing his expenses.

In a statement to the Evening Standard Brian Coleman said:

“I won’t do it voluntarily. It’s none of the public’s business. They have coped well without knowing this kind of detail for more that 75 years.

They are not entitled to drool over our personal lives. I’m not going to help the mad, bad and the sad, the bloggers on the internet. I’m not pandering to mob rule. It undermines democracy to suggest that all MPs, all politicians are the spawn of Beelzebub.

Nobody is going to go into public life if they think the minutiae of their grocery bills are going to be looked over.

Politicians with lower expenses tend to be the politicians who do least work. Those with higher expenses are the ones who do most work.

I’m from the Boris school of anarchist thinking. If somebody tells me to do something, I don’t want to do it.

In response a close ally to Boris Johnson said:

Boris has made it clear from day one that transparency and openness are the heart of his administration.

He is disappointed when any Assembly member doesn’t appreciate that the public rightly expect to know what’s being done by their elected representatives in their name and with their money.

So will Boris have the guts to fire Brian Coleman?

The London mayor is also under fire for cronyism. He is accused of trying to parachute in his policy director, the former journalist Anthony Browne, on to the independent London Development Agency:

the Guardian reported:

Boris Johnson, the London mayor, today faced accusations of creating a possible “conflict of interest” over his decision to place one of his senior aides on the board of the London Development Agency.

The LDA is London’s regional development agency and operates under the political leadership of the mayor. It approves or rejects funding for mayoral plans on an independent basis, though the mayor can exercise his powers of directions, in effect overruling the board’s decision.

Adam Bienkov at Tory Troll says:

What does that say about Boris’s commitment to “transparency and openness” and what does that say about his continuing ability to choose the wrong man for the job?

And what’s Brian Coleman’s reaction to all of this? Is he shamed, contrite, or repentant? Don’t be silly.


---------------------------
  Tweet   Share on Tumblr  


About the author
Chris is a regular contributor to Liberal Conspiracy. He is an aspiring journalist and reports stories for LC.
· Other posts by


Story Filed Under: Blog ,Local Government ,London Mayor


Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.


Reader comments


1. Sunder Katwala

Surely the Conservatives have to ‘withdraw the whip’ or whatever the GLA equivalent is and make Coleman sit as an independent and make clear he can’t stand for them next time.

Shouldn’t there be a push to call on them to do that?

2. IanVisits

So will Boris have the guts to fire Brian Coleman?

Ummm, just how does the Mayor fire an elected politician?

Brian Coleman’s are stupid and asinine – but then again, so is your demand that the Mayor should sack an elected politician. That lies with the electorate, not the Mayor.

@2, he’s chair of Boris’s Fire & Emergency Planning Authority. Hence, Boris could sack him. Asinine indeed.

If there’s anyone posting here with any knowledge of how Tory party internal discipline works, it’d be interesting to hear whether Boris / Dave / anyone else would be able to withdraw the whip.

4. Richard (the original)

Tar and feather the tosser.

There’s a slightly wider point here, which is that ‘cronyism’, as in ‘appointing people you know and trust to jobs in your power’ isn’t actually that big a problem – the structure of the GLA and Mayoralty actually means you can’t run it efficiently any other way. What’s the alternative? Open recruitment, as for any other public sector job? The structure is explicitly designed not to replicate the failures of the civil service, and to act essentially as a way for the Mayor to do things – that’s been both the criticism and the strength of an elected Mayor, after all – he has all the power and thus all the responsibilty. There’s no room for a Cabinet, despite the election promise.

Boris’s problems don’t, therefore, come from cronyism, but from him repeatedly appointing people recommended by others and finding that they either don’t listen to him or came with their own agendas. It’s not particularly surprising that he’s reducing back to basically putting his journo mates into jobs. The burnt child fears the fire, or at least fears Francis Maude and Nick Boles and their bright ideas.

What does matter, and where Coleman, Clement etc. fall right into a hole, is that you have to have transparency, particularly in the disbursement of money, making meetings available online, webcasts etc., to try and reduce the temptation to corruption and favouritism. Here Boris is in danger of finding himself in the astonishing position of being outflanked by Labour on one of his core commitments (for instance Navin Shah’s attempts to put the LFEPA’s expenses on a more transparent footing, which incidentally has a strong probability of rendering Coleman’s position untenable, and the rest of the Assembly volunteering to publish itemised expenses before the vote to make it compulsory from 15/7/2009). What with Coleman’s shenanigans, the publishing of all Mayoral advisor expenses is rather lost, despite being, on the face of it, a progressive move.

6. Charlieman

Who owns the content (data) in an expenses claim? The London Assembly or the Member?


Reactions: Twitter, blogs
  1. Liberal Conspiracy

    Article: Tory sticks up two fingers at Boris, amidst cronyism http://bit.ly/18lhMi





Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.

 
Liberal Conspiracy is the UK's most popular left-of-centre politics blog. Our aim is to re-vitalise the liberal-left through discussion and action. More about us here.

You can read articles through the front page, via Twitter or RSS feed. You can also get them by email and through our Facebook group.
LATEST COMMENT PIECES
» The Boris brand is weaker than his friends think
» Nine things you can do to halt Lansley’s destruction of our NHS
» Incidents like this shame us all
» Taxpayers Alliance want to cut taxes, mostly for the rich
» We’re turning The Spirit Level into a film: help us in that goal
» I love the counter-productive attitude of right-wing commentators
» Watch out for the TPA’s report arguing for more cuts tomorrow
» The resurgence of bigoted conservatism in Ireland
» What’s the point of being ‘British’?
» The tragedy behind the Sam Hallam case
» Will JP Morgan be able to walk away from billion dollar losses?
» Labour is now even more reliant on left-wing voters






13 Comments



13 Comments



56 Comments



41 Comments



19 Comments



13 Comments



30 Comments



116 Comments



25 Comments



33 Comments



LATEST COMMENTS
» So Much For Subtlety posted on Frank Field wrong on workless households

» Incidents like this shame us all | Black Triangle Campaign posted on Incidents like this shame us all

» Barney posted on Funny bits of TPA report you probably missed

» So Much For Subtlety posted on Incidents like this shame us all

» P Ve M posted on Public DOES want gay marriage, Lords reform

» So Much For Subtlety posted on Incidents like this shame us all

» So Much For Subtlety posted on TPA report quotes Bible to preach low taxation

» John77 posted on Taxpayers Alliance want to cut taxes, mostly for the rich

» dave bones posted on The Boris brand is weaker than his friends think

» Robin Levett posted on Funny bits of TPA report you probably missed

» the a&e charge nurse posted on Nine things you can do to halt Lansley's destruction of our NHS

» damon posted on The Boris brand is weaker than his friends think

» eastender posted on The Boris brand is weaker than his friends think

» Just Visiting posted on Funny bits of TPA report you probably missed

» Just Visiting posted on TPA report quotes Bible to preach low taxation