Today, Jeremy Clarkson – when asked his opinion on the strikes, said: “I would have them all shot”.
He added:
I would take them outside and execute them in front of their families.
I mean how dare they go on strike when they have these gilt-edged pensions that are going to be guaranteed, while the rest of us have to work for a living.
Does that look like comedy?
I have two issues here.
First, the BBC has major voices on the right that regularly opine about national politics (Andrew Neil, Jeremy Clarkson, Nick Robinson) – and those are just the major ones – while there are hardly any similar left-wing figures. The only ones you occasionally get (Armando Ianucci, David Mitchell and Charlie Brooker) – are explicitly non-partisan, mostly anti-establishment in general and pointedly comedians. The first two also voted Libdem (as I did) at the last election, not Labour.
Mehdi Hasan has written about the myth of the left-wing BBC too, and this continuously grates on me. The BBC’s willingness to take Clarkson’s seriously is not balanced at all by an equivalent left personality.
Secondly, this isn’t really a joke – because he repeats with quite a serious face the lie that they have ‘gold plated pensions’. There was nothing funny in it.
It is a naked attempt to push the debate even further to the right, in the way that Republicans in the US keep repeating the lie that Obama is a Marxist-socialist. We take it as a joke because we know it rubbish but it’s a dog-whistle to a whole bunch of people out there who hang on to their ever word. It matters because extreme stuff like this becomes part of the national discourse on the right…whereas if anyone left-wing says anything vaguely controversial they’d be sacked from the BBC.
—
PS – Let’s not have Tories complaining about ‘PC gawn mad’ and ‘have a sense of humour’ when they get so uppity and annoyed at even small jokes themselves.