Home Westminster UnionsMedia Activism

Embryology Bill: in defence of liberation biology


by Dave Osler    
March 27, 2008 at 11:33 am

Christians are surely the last people who should be getting uptight about healing the sick; after all, Jesus was reportedly a bit of a dab hand at it himself.

OK, I’ve never actually read the Douay-Rheims Bible on which I presume Cardinal Keith O’Brien bases his teachings on. But according to the King James Version that I am familar with, Christ cured dozens of people with ailments ranging from unspecified fever, leprosy, menorrhagia and/or haemophilia, withered limbs, dropsy, deafness, blindness and paralysis. What’s more – unlike the average NHS general practitioner – he didn’t even have a problem with Saturday call-outs.

All of this makes Christ a tough act to follow. But humanity could be on the verge of doing just that.

Thanks to stem cell research, for the first time in 2000 years, it may be possible for those with broken spines once more to walk. Soon doctors might be able to inject insulin-producing cells into diabetics, and treat effectively for the first time multiple sclerosis and motor neurone disease. I mention MS and MND for a reason; the first killed my mother, the second a friend only a couple of years older than I am.

Yet the One, Holy, Catholic and Apostolic church – basing itself on 13th century Thomist natural law theology – is effectively saying that those in the future with the diseases from which my mum and Richard suffered so much for decades before dying lingering and painful deaths should be denied a possible cure.

As things stand, scientists do not have enough fully human stem cells to research on in order to ensure the necessary medical breakthroughs are achieved. That is why they are asking to be allowed to take animal eggs and inject them with DNA. We are talking cells in a test tube here, nothing more grotesque than that.

Yet there are those ostensibly on the left who believe that the very Catholicism that would forbid this qualitative leap offers some kind of ‘moral compass’ for Britain today; for me, any moral compass that postulates a morally perfect God – and that is an essential tenet of all three major monotheisms – would dictate strong backing for the Embryo Research Bill.

Surely Catholic MPs of all major parties – not least leading figures in a Labour government who purport to be torn on this question – can see that? For the record, I do favour politicians having the right to abstain on legislation on conscience grounds, not least because in the entirely hypothetical event that I ever hold public office, I expect that I would routingly invoke it.

However, I must agree with one leftwing blogger, who points out that few enough ‘pro-life’ MPs utilised such an obvious get-out when it came to trooping through the lobby in favour of mass slaughter in Iraq.

Never mind liberation theology. The left should be fully in support of what science writer Ronald Bailey has called liberation biology against both bioconservatives and bioluddites.

As his book points out, the biotech revolution promise even those of us who are healthy an additional 20-40 years on their lifespan. Catholics, evangelicals and other such confident believers in an afterlife are perfectly free to turn down such an opportunity.

As I expect to be a long time dead – and given that I am in a final salary pension scheme – I’d jump at that chance. The sooner the boffins do the business – and the picture illustrates them doing just that – the better.


-------------------------

  Tweet  

About the author
Dave Osler is a regular contributor. He is a British journalist and author, ex-punk and ex-Trot. Also at: Dave's Part
· Other posts by Dave Osler

Filed under
Blog ,Labour party ,Westminster


2 responses in total   ||  



Reader comments

What is the Workers’ Weekly line on final salary pension schemes?!
You’re surely not planning to live off the fruits of capitalist exploitation?

For most people not on a final salary scheme – ie most people not in the public sector -an extra 20-40 years of life will mean an extra 20-40 years of work!
Now that would be an interesting conflict: public sector retires at 60; private at 100.

Though I am in favour of the bill…

2. douglas clark

Dave,

What the boffins are holding out is not to be scoffed at. It is, however, at this moment, speculative. I am completely in favour of stem cell research. There should be as few barriers as possible to it. However, I was a victim of ‘Tomorrows World’, and promises should be taken with a pinch of salt.

If it succeeds in alieviating either MS or MND then it is worth it.

Just saying about the hype.

Believe it when you see it.


Reactions: Twitter, blogs


    Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.

     
    Liberal Conspiracy is the UK's most popular left-of-centre politics blog. Our aim is to re-vitalise the liberal-left through discussion and action. More about us here.

    You can read articles through the front page, via Twitter or RSS feed.
    RECENT OPINION ARTICLES
    TwitterRSS feedsRSS feedsFacebook


    13 Comments



    41 Comments



    39 Comments



    33 Comments



    19 Comments



    33 Comments



    34 Comments



    71 Comments



    146 Comments



    200 Comments



    LATEST COMMENTS
    » Leon posted on Why we want to ‘recall’ Aaron Porter as NUS President

    » Vladimir posted on What if Superdrug lived up to its name?

    » Just Visiting posted on What if Superdrug lived up to its name?

    » Staffordshire UNISON posted on IFS: Child Poverty to rise due to Coalition plans

    » Staffordshire UNISON posted on More Vodafone and Topshop protests coming

    » Sunny Hundal posted on IFS: Child Poverty to rise due to Coalition plans

    » Deb posted on More Vodafone and Topshop protests coming

    » Jacob Richardson posted on More Vodafone and Topshop protests coming

    » Tom Miller posted on Left unity and the bid to oust Aaron Porter

    » TeresaMary posted on IFS: Child Poverty to rise due to Coalition plans

    » Chris Goulden posted on IFS: Child Poverty to rise due to Coalition plans

    » nick terry posted on More light finally shed on the allegations against Julian Assange

    » Miss A posted on Prosecutors urge care on retracted rape claims

    » Deb posted on More Vodafone and Topshop protests coming

    » smileandsubvert posted on More Vodafone and Topshop protests coming