The Slow Death of the DWP ‘Lie Detector’
More than a year ago, Liberal Conspiracy published a short series of briefings on a controversial trial of a so-called ‘voice risk analysis’ system by the Department of Work and Pensions.
Yesterday, the ultimate fate of these systems was revealed in a rather terse response to a parlimentary question tabled by the Tory MP for East Yorkshire, Greg Knight:
Chris Grayling (Minister of State (Employment), Work and Pensions
In 2008-09 a total of £1,734,314.07 was paid directly to the 24 local authorities involved in voice risk analysis pilots. There was no DWP funding for voice risk analysis in subsequent years. The pilots finished in December 2009. Local authorities can continue to use voice risk analysis at their own discretion and at their own expense.
LC briefing: Lie detectors – where your money is going
For this LC briefing, using Freedom of Information requests, I can tell you exactly how much taxpayers’ money has been spent on the trial to date and exactly where this technology is being used to vet benefits claimants.
If James Purnell’s department did decide to roll out this system nationally, one company could, within the next five years, build an effective monopoly over the processing of welfare benefit claims worth tens of millions, if not hundreds of millions, of pounds a year.
So here’s the breakdown, and a little surprise I uncovered last week…
LC briefing: DWP on Trial – a quick update
Yesterday, the Guardian technology supplement carried a story that covers a part of our briefing, specifically the threat of a libel action by Amir Liberman/Nemesysco against two Swedish reseachers who published a paper criticising the ‘lie detector’.
continue reading… »
LC briefing: Lie detectors – how it all started
Time for some background to this story. The public sector business services contracts company Capita are behind the DWP trial. In fact all the local authorities involved in the trial have IT services and outsourcing contracts with Capita. This notice verifies that.
In November 2004, Capita acquired the full shareholding in an insurance claims investigation company called Brownsword Ltd from private equity investors, ISIS Equity Partners. In buying out Brownsword, Capita also acquired an exclusive 10 year licence, from another company (DigiLog UK) for what DigiLog calls its ‘Advanced Validation Solutions’ – this is the same system that the DWP are trialling and at the heart of that system lies the controversial ‘voice risk analysis’ software we’ve been investigating.
As some readers have already noted, this software-based system, which its developer calls ‘Layered Voice Analysis’ (LVA), was developed from a patent filed in 1997 by an Israeli national, Amir Liberman, and is currently owned and marketed by Liberman’s company, Nemesysco. DigiLog UK is Nemesysco’s UK agent and distributor.
So far, we’ve referred to this system as a ‘lie detector’, but in fact, Nemesysco makes a number of much more expansive claims for its technology on its website.
continue reading… »
LC briefing: editor’s note
Last year Hazel Blears MP (in)famously said most blogs did little to ‘add value’ to our political culture. If by ‘value’, Blears did not mean bloggers doing research into government initiatives and occasionally exposing them for the gimmicks they are, then she probably won’t be pleased with our briefing either.
Today, coincidentally, David Hencke asks if James Purnell is the worst social security minister ever: I’d say he is in contention for the worst Labour minister ever given how empty his initiatives at the DWP have been. His plans to trial lie detectors to tackle benefit fraud will eventually be exposed as one of those vacuous stunts.
First a bit of background.
continue reading… »
Liberal Conspiracy briefing: Exposing the DWP’s lie detector testing
Hello LC readers I have a treat for you. Today we start publishing the first of our briefings – a document I’ve been working on for the past month or so. It’s not coming out all at once because there are some legal and other issues still to be resolved. But in coming days and weeks, more will be revealed.
Our focus is on the Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) and in particular its recent decision to use lie detection technology to catch out benefit claimants.
We think that this is not only unethical, but the technology itself is so prone to error as to be useless for the purpose for which is it supposedly intended. So why is the DWP spending over a million pounds promoting it across local authorities? Has it done research into its drawbacks and limitations? If yes, then why is it still using it?
You can read articles through the front page, via Twitter or RSS feed.
» The Slow Death of the DWP ‘Lie Detector’
» John Hirst and making the case for prisoners’ votes
» Will Israel’s public snub of William Hague force another Libdem u-turn?
» Why the left should champion a softer approach to drugs
» More evidence Tories know little about Trade unions
» Exposed: Capita reveals it is “targeting” NHS Direct as an outsourcing project
» US mid-terms: Republicans win but Democrats have bright spots
» Roshonara Choudhry and Muslim alienation
» Why the Vodafone protests have already been successful
» Ignore the media, there are good reasons why Obama will lose today
» Coalition in-fighting over Control Orders goes public
|
4 Comments 14 Comments 13 Comments 31 Comments 15 Comments 38 Comments 32 Comments 7 Comments 13 Comments 51 Comments |
|
LATEST COMMENTS » Tania posted on EXCLUSIVE: Phil Woolas authorised use of force to deport immigrant children » Tim Ireland posted on EXCLUSIVE: Phil Woolas authorised use of force to deport immigrant children » thejudgemuffin posted on EXCLUSIVE: Phil Woolas authorised use of force to deport immigrant children » Oliver Conner posted on EXCLUSIVE: Phil Woolas authorised use of force to deport immigrant children » Gubbs posted on EXCLUSIVE: Phil Woolas authorised use of force to deport immigrant children » Jacob Uzzell posted on EXCLUSIVE: Phil Woolas authorised use of force to deport immigrant children » Joseph Hurdman posted on EXCLUSIVE: Phil Woolas authorised use of force to deport immigrant children » Dan Hodges posted on EXCLUSIVE: Phil Woolas authorised use of force to deport immigrant children » MCF posted on EXCLUSIVE: Phil Woolas authorised use of force to deport immigrant children » Peter Pannier posted on EXCLUSIVE: Phil Woolas authorised use of force to deport immigrant children » Islam Europe posted on EXCLUSIVE: Phil Woolas authorised use of force to deport immigrant children » Islam Europe posted on EXCLUSIVE: Phil Woolas authorised use of force to deport immigrant children » Stuart Robertson posted on EXCLUSIVE: Phil Woolas authorised use of force to deport immigrant children » Stuart Robertson posted on EXCLUSIVE: Phil Woolas authorised use of force to deport immigrant children » James Hoare posted on EXCLUSIVE: Phil Woolas authorised use of force to deport immigrant children |
